What the markets have told us about the GNU and how they will continue to do so

You might have expected more volatile markets, in this election year. The evidence however suggests otherwise. Investors on the JSE and the New York Stock Exchanges have coped comfortably well with the potential dangers.  Daily volatility on both share markets, the scale of daily ups and downs in average share prices, has been unusually subdued, and well below long term averages in the US. Electing a scoundrel or a cognitively challenged US President has not made much of a difference to stability in the US markets The coalition outcome in SA proved welcome but not much of a surprise, again as judged by volatility trends. The Volatility Index for the S&P 500 – the VIX-  also known as the Fear Index- has averaged 13 this year well below a daily long-term average 2000-2024 of 19. The equivalent construct for the JSE, the SA Volatility Index (SAVI) – with a similar long-term average of 21, has also trended lower this year.

As may be easily observed the chances of an Index or any well traded share moving higher or lower on any day are about the same. The pattern is thus of a random walk, of ups being matched by downs of roughly the same average magnitude. Yet happily for shareholders these movements have come with a slight upward bias, above a daily average of zero, to provide shareholders with positive returns over the longer run. If they stayed invested in the share market the end result has been strongly positive annual returns over five or ten year periods rolled back each month.

(See below the daily moves of the S&P 500 and the JSE All Share Index in 2024. We also show the Daily SAVI in 2023-24 as well as actual volatility of the JSE – calculated as the rolling 30 day Standard Deviation about the Daily Average Share Pirce Move)

Daily % Share Index Movements on the JSE and the S&P 500 in 2024

Source; Bloomberg and Investec Wealth & Investment

Daily Moves in the SA Volatility Index (SAVI) and Volatility Measured as the Standard Deviation of the JSE (Annualised as a rolling 30-day average)

Source; Bloomberg and Investec Wealth & Investment

When daily volatility is more elevated, share prices will change consistently in the opposite direction. When the VIX or SAVI goes up share prices go down most days. They do so to improve the chances of higher risk adjusted returns- off a lower entry price- to compensate for more risk incurred.  And vice versa. In 2024 it has been vice versa in the US and in SA- risks have fallen and values have improved.  Extra risk comes with more returns and vice versa as nature intends. (see below)

The average move for the JSE in 2024 in the six months to June 2024 was an encouraging 0.27% per day. The S&P did only half as well- providing an average gain of 0.11% per day.   

Daily % Changes in the VIX and the S&P 500 in 2024. Scatter Plot

Source; Bloomberg and Investec Wealth & Investment

Daily % Changes in the SAVI and the JSE in 2024. Scatter Plot

Source; Bloomberg and Investec Wealth & Investment

It is the quality of economic policy, more than the presumed certainty of such policies, good bad or somewhere in between, that will matter much more for financial markets in the long run. Any willingness of investors to accord a SA facing business an  extended economic life will also add to present values. Provided the Return on Equity (ROE) exceeds the opportunity cost of capital, faster expected growth for a longer term, can explode the current present value of a share and market multiples. Price over Current Earnings or Cash flows and Market to Book ratios.

An accompaniment of lower ROE’s and a lower discount rate attached to future surpluses would also add much additional market value to SA companies.  And to their willingness and ability to undertake and fund growth enhancing capex and employment. Faster growth if realised will add to an extra flow of cash to the government, bringing less risk to the fiscal outlook. And be reflected in lower interest and discount rates across the board and in higher share prices.

Extra wealth created in the bond and equity markets, is a game played by all with formal employment and retirement plans, and not only the richer few. The capital markets will provide an objective measure of the performance of the government of national unity (GNU) The score will be continuously kept and updated. While investors have not been frightened by the GNU, they have still to give approval. Over to the GNU.

Taking advantage of risk aversion

Dealing with Covid in 2020 was a frightening episode. The JSE All Share Index lost 20% of its value by March that year and the S&P 500, suffered a very similar drawdown, of 20% in USD. Yet something predictable then followed. Between January 2020 and July 2024 share markets have given very good returns and they have outperformed bonds and cash by large margins. R100 invested in the JSE immediately pre Covid with dividends reinvested, would now be worth R173. Had the R100 been invested in the S&P 500 it would now be worth significantly more R236. The same R100 if invested in the Bond Index or in a money market fund with interest reinvested would have grown to only R144 and R130 respectively.

Cumulative Returns by Asset Classes (2020=100)

Source; Bloomberg and Investec Wealth & Investment

A predictable outcome–given the large outperformance by a representative share portfolio on the JSE since 2000, or for that matter also since 1980 or 1960. The R100 invested in the JSE Index in 2000 would have grown to R2152 that is by 21 times at an annual average rate of return of 13.12% p.a. The R100 in money market would have grown by 6.3 times and the Bond Index by 10.6 times over the same period. Incidentally the JSE has kept up with the S&P also measured in rands over these 24 years. The JSE outperformed significantly until 2010 and has underperformed since.

The JSE has therefore recovered very well from significant periodic drawdowns since 2000, 40% down in 2002, 51% in 2008, 24% after Covid and 15% with Fed tightening in 2022.

The JSE All Share Index Cumulative Returns (2000=100) Per Cent Draw Downs Indicated on X axis

Source; Bloomberg and Investec Wealth & Investment

Equities are expected to give superior returns because they are more risky to hold than cash or bonds. The higher returns expected of equities compensate for the different risk of losses investors believe they are exposed to holding shares. Higher expected returns mean lower entry prices for investors,  all else remaining the same. And these expected extra returns have been delivered to date by most Stock Exchanges.

Share prices move each day about an average of close to zero. They demonstrate a random walk with hopefully upward drift to give the expected positive returns over the long run. The more difficulty investors have in interpreting the news about a company or an economy, the wider are the daily swings in prices in both directions. This volatility gives rise to an objective measure of risk. It will be reflected in the cost of an option to insure against volatility. Investors can buy or sell a volatility index, the VIX, based on the underlying volatility of the S&P 500. When S&P volatility (risk) rises share prices fall. And vice versa They do so to improve or reduce prospective returns, in a statistically significant way.  As has again been the case this year.

Risk and Return on the S&P 500 in 2024 (Daily % Moves in the S&P Index and the VIX) R = (-0.68)

Source; Bloomberg and Investec Wealth & Investment

Yet were share market returns measured over longer periods, the risk of an in period loss falls significantly. The average returns when investing on the JSE or S&P market are very similar when returns are measured over one, five or ten year holding periods. Since 2020 returns for holding the S&P Index have averaged about 14% over one year and 11.1% p.a. and 11.2% p.a. when calculated over consecutive five year and ten-year periods respectiverly. However, the Standard Deviation (SD) of returns about the average has been much higher for one-year returns (13.87) than for five or ten year returns with SD’s of 2.93 and 1.96. The same relationship holds when the analysis is taken back to 2000. Risks (the SD or volatility of returns) have fallen sharply when the investment period is extended beyond one year. Absolute losses when returns are measured over five- or ten-year periods occur rarely. It took a Financial Crisis to do so.

The extra expected returns for extra equity risk applies to the averagely risk-averse investor with limited wealth. When you are investing for you children and grandchildren and their children, and are wealthy enough not to have to worry about being forced to cash in your shares, you can invest without much risk -and you can expect to pick up the money left on the table by the more risk averse.  Further support for time in the market – not timing the market.

Returns on the S&P 500 Index. Over One, five and ten year periods.  Monthly Data 2020- 2024.

Source; Bloomberg and Investec Wealth & Investment